If you are getting into music production, you may wonder whether you need a MIDI keyboard or a piano. They may look similar, but they serve two very different purposes.
The simplest explanation is this: a piano produces its own sound, while a MIDI keyboard controls sounds on your computer.
I have played piano for roughly 25 years and produced music for more than 10 years. After using several different MIDI controllers, I currently use the Arturia KeyLab Essential MK3 49-key MIDI keyboard. It gives me enough keys to play melodies and chords without taking over my entire desk.
Disclosure: This article contains an affiliate link. I may earn a commission if you purchase through it, at no additional cost to you.
What Is a MIDI Keyboard?
A MIDI keyboard is a controller that sends musical information to your computer. It tells software such as FL Studio, Ableton Live or Logic Pro which notes you played, how hard you pressed them and how long you held them.
The keyboard itself normally does not create the sound. Your DAW and virtual instruments generate the piano, guitar, synthesizer, bass or other sounds you hear.
This gives producers a huge advantage: the same keyboard can control thousands of different sounds. You can record a melody with a piano sound and then change it to a synthesizer without playing the part again.
What Is a Piano?
A traditional or digital piano is a standalone instrument designed primarily for playing piano. You can sit down, turn it on or open the lid, and begin playing without loading a program on your computer.
Digital pianos commonly have 61, 76 or 88 keys. Many also use weighted keys to recreate the resistance and feel of an acoustic piano.
Here is an interesting comparison: a full-size piano has 88 keys, but a 49-key MIDI controller can still access the same overall note range by using its octave buttons. You simply cannot play all 88 notes at the same time.
MIDI Keyboard vs. Piano: Quick Comparison
| Feature | MIDI Keyboard | Piano |
|---|---|---|
| Produces its own sound | Usually no | Yes |
| Requires a computer | Usually yes | No |
| Best for | Beat-making and music production | Traditional piano practice and performance |
| Typical size | 25, 49, 61 or 88 keys | 61, 76 or 88 keys |
| Extra controls | Pads, knobs, faders and transport controls | Usually limited |
Watch: MIDI Keyboard vs. Piano Explained
Why I Use a 49-Key MIDI Keyboard
I consider myself a serious piano player, but I still use a 49-key controller for music production. It is the sweet spot for my home studio because it gives me enough room to play with both hands while still fitting comfortably on my desk.
Desk space is something producers often overlook. A 61-key or 88-key controller may sound better on paper, but it can become awkward if it pushes your computer keyboard, mouse or monitor out of position.
After trying several MIDI keyboards throughout more than a decade of producing, the Arturia KeyLab Essential MK3 is the one I recommend most. It is also the keyboard I actually use—not simply a product I found online.
It includes keys, drum pads, knobs and faders, plus a useful software package with additional sounds. That makes it a strong centerpiece for a home production setup.
View My MIDI Keyboard on Amazon
If it fits your budget and studio space, open the Amazon listing, choose the version you want and add it to your cart so you can compare it with any other controllers you are considering.
What About Weighted Keys?
Weighted keys can make a digital keyboard feel more like a traditional piano. That can be valuable if your main goal is learning classical piano or developing traditional playing technique.
For beat-making, however, fully weighted keys are not always necessary. In FL Studio, I can manually adjust note velocity after recording. Sometimes I even prefer a consistent response because it reduces the amount of correction needed to make the melody sit properly in the beat.
This comes down to your workflow. If realistic piano performance is the priority, consider weighted keys. If you mainly create beats, melodies and chord progressions, a responsive semi-weighted MIDI controller may be more practical.
Should You Buy a MIDI Keyboard or a Piano?
Choose a MIDI keyboard if:
- You want to make beats or produce complete songs.
- You work in FL Studio, Ableton Live, Logic Pro or another DAW.
- You want to control different virtual instruments and sounds.
- You want drum pads, knobs or faders built into your keyboard.
- You need something that fits on a studio desk.
Choose a piano or digital piano if:
- Your main goal is learning or performing piano.
- You want to play without connecting to a computer.
- You want 88 weighted keys and a realistic piano feel.
- You primarily need high-quality built-in piano sounds.
If your main goal is music production, I would choose a MIDI keyboard. It provides much more control over your software and gives you access to far more sounds than a standard piano.
Need Help Choosing the Right Size?
If you are still deciding between 25, 49, 61 and 88 keys, view my free MIDI Keyboard Buyer’s Guide. It explains how to choose a controller based on your desk space, workflow and experience level.
View the Free MIDI Keyboard Buyer’s Guide
Final Recommendation
A piano is a standalone instrument that is ready to play on its own. A MIDI keyboard is a flexible studio controller that lets you perform and record sounds from your music software.
For most beat-makers and home producers, a 49-key MIDI keyboard offers the best balance of playability and desk space. That is why I continue to use the Arturia KeyLab Essential MK3 after years of testing different controllers.
